Reasons for Having a Baby Good and Bad

Source: Monkey Business Images/Shutterstock

I've been interviewing adult daughters of unloving mothers for about a decade and the second most poignant question—later "Why didn't she love me?"—is commonly "Why did she have me?" Sometimes, the question is more rhetorical than not. But it usually hangs there, heavy, waiting for an answer that will never come up, one that might begin to explain why a mother treated her girl as she did.

Why people have children is complicated, of class. For millennia, even though there were documented efforts at birth control in every society beginning with ancient Egypt (and doubtless before that), people had children because it was hard to avoid having them. In agrarian and tribal societies, children were not only a potential labor forcefulness simply likewise members of a clan. Sons provided a manner of protecting property from one generation to another. Daughters, especially highly marriageable ones, offered a way of establishing new bonds and consolidating and acquiring ability and appurtenances. And, yes, even so, people had children simply because they wanted them.

Whether having a child makes you lot happier than you might have been without one remains highly debatable, as contradictory studies show. While almost studies testify lowered subjective well-being among people with children, Angus Deaton and Arthur A. Stone have recently argued that the results are misleading. While people living with children report more than stress, they as well report more than happiness. They tend, perhaps not coincidentally, to be meliorate educated, healthier, more probable to be married, more religious—all of which too may contribute to happiness. In a similar vein, Chris Herbst and John Ifcher investigated whether a "parental happiness gap" reported in popular media existed. They found that while levels of subjective well-being had declined amongst not-parents, they had improved amongst parents in recent years. They conjectured that, possibly, children provided a buffer of sorts against sure negative trends, amid them economic instability and lack of social connection in an increasingly narcissistic society.

More than to the point, cheers to reliable birth control and changing mores, becoming a parent is now more of a selection than ever. According to the U.S. Census Bureau, 47.vi% of women between the ages of 15 and 44 did not have children in 2014, the highest percentage since tracking began in 1976. Just under one-half (49.6%) of women betwixt 25 and 29 were childless, as were 28.9% of those between thirty and 34.

Every bit choosing not to have a child becomes more acceptable in the twenty-offset century—aye, information technology's now called childfree, non childless—more people are making that choice. I'm non sure almost the term "childfree" because of what it implies about the "burden" of parenting. As well, it's a bit hyperbolic. For example, while I know a number of women and men who don't accept their own children for various and sundry reasons, all of them have close connections to children—nieces and nephews, the children of friends and neighbors, equally well as mentees. That isn't precisely childfree in my opinion.

Interestingly, the shift in the civilization—moving abroad from the 1950s stance when the assumption most a couple without a kid was that if they didn't have one, they couldn't have one—has prompted somewhat of a more open dialogue near parenting. (I say "somewhat" advisedly considering almost of the discussions near mothering are still animated by the cultural mythology of all women being instinctually suited for motherhood and nurturing.) Both privately and publicly, men and women confess disappointment with individual children and, indeed, with parenting itself. Equally a father of two children now in their thirties, with whom he has express contact, put information technology: "I think if I had information technology to do all over again, I wouldn't accept had children. If I'd been honest with myself then, I would have realized I was having kids because I was supposed to and my wife wanted them." Similarly, a woman in her eighties, the mother of a son and daughter, observed that she wished she'd had the selection not to have children because, ultimately, she found the globe of work much more than gratifying than the 20 years she spent as a housewife and female parent. I've been in conversations during which parents, sounding somewhat envious, annotation that their childfree friends and acquaintances wait younger, are less stressed, and take more than money and resources. This does non mean, of course, that they do non dear the children they take, simply it does reflect how active a selection becoming a parent has get.

I volition readily admit that I have a stake in this discussion and firmly believe that the decision to become a parent is a weighty 1 that should exist fabricated as consciously every bit possible. I say that not merely equally an unloved girl who has listened to hundreds and hundreds of stories from children who were not, in the truest sense, loved past their mothers or fathers, only also as someone who had decided not to have children and then, nearing age twoscore, reversed herself. I at present consider motherhood the crowning achievement of my life—and for a feminist, this is quite a statement. This is not to say that I am ever successful at mothering (just ask my daughter) or that I haven't fabricated mistakes. I have, and I recognize that what I have done wrong has shaped my kid simply as surely, and probably more than so, than the things I take done right. Research has consistently confirmed that the hurt you inflict carries greater weight and more influence than the good you impart. Information technology is simply role of a man's hardwiring: "Bad is stronger than good."

Yet, at that place are good reasons to take a child and some truly bad ones. Here are some of the actually bad reasons I have gleaned from many conversations with mothers and daughters, fathers and sons:

1. To take someone who loves you.

I've had a number of women, all of whom had babies very young, make this confession. In most cases they explain that having a baby seemed to offer a respite from the pain of unloving parents or rejecting relationships with lovers or spouses. One woman reflected on the conclusion she made many decades ago to have a child on her ain without the participation of the father who was basically a one-night stand. She called it "the most selfish thing I have ever done." Another remarked that "children shouldn't have children," acknowledging that she had neither the emotional stability nor the maturity to truly mother the kid she had. The real problem, of course, is that the brunt of supplying love is shifted onto the child who is supposed to be emotional first assistance for the parent. That is a recipe for disaster.

2. Considering someone expects yous to.

Information technology doesn't matter who that someone is—a parent, a spouse, or societal pressure. Having a child is a conclusion you need to ain on every level because it is an enormous commitment. The work that adept parenting requires is far too intense and enervating to be inspired by anyone'southward expectations other than your own. People who stumble into parenthood this way ordinarily practice then without taking a personal inventory of their own needs or, more importantly, their own abilities to care for and be responsive to someone who utterly depends on them. The children of these parents often study that while their physical needs were taken care of—yes, there was a roof over their heads, clothes on their back, food on the tabular array—their emotional needs were largely ignored.

iii. To fit in.

Yes, some women actually acknowledge that they were afraid that others would somehow shun or stigmatize them if they decided non to accept a kid. Possibly they would seem "less than" women with children. If we are honest with ourselves virtually so-called cultural "norms," we would recognize that this is really a legitimate worry for many. Nonetheless, information technology isn't a healthy motivation to commit to parenting. One woman who, in conjunction with her married man, decided not to take children, observed: "I am i of 4 sisters and the but one without kids. That set me apart, and not in a proficient way either, especially since I was capable of having them. Both my parents and my siblings saw my choice equally 'proof' of how selfish and cocky-involved I was. When my parents died, I received far less than my sisters did and the will even noted that I didn't need every bit much since it was just me lonely."

4. To requite your life purpose.

While information technology's true that raising a kid can give your life focus and purpose, it'southward a lousy reason to have a child. You lot are the but person who tin define what gives your life pregnant. It's non an obligation that can be fulfilled by another human being, not even one you requite nativity to. This reason (and the next) can easily become enmeshment—which involves denying the child the room she needs to become herself and totally ignoring her emotional boundaries—or micromanagement. A kid'south chore isn't to make your life look amend or richer than it actually is.

5. To constitute your legacy.

Dynasty, protection of material appurtenances and avails, and a need to leave something behind in the wake of mortality have all, historically, been reasons to take a child. Simply that doesn't give them any more emotional or psychological validity. Like those who have children to give their lives purpose, mothers concerned with legacy meet children as extensions of themselves and, as reported by many daughters, put enormous pressure level on their children to reverberate well on them. In this scenario, what the children want—and, for that matter, what they feel and think—are largely ignored. As one daughter told me, "Information technology was hugely important to my mother that I be admired so that she could be admired past others for having raised me. She picked my clothes, my friends, fifty-fifty the college I went to, based on how 'enviable' information technology would seem to her social circle. I became a lawyer because she wanted me to. When I finally realized I hated practicing constabulary, my female parent freaked out, especially when I went from this loftier-paying, prestigious profession to, in her stance, the lowly work of teaching in public schoolhouse. She mentions it constantly and belittles me for my choices." Fathers oft have children for the same reasons, equally one adult son, ane of five children, recounted: "The pressure on all of my father'due south sons to succeed was enormous considering whatever slip, annihilation less than 'start rate,' reflected badly on him. It was truthful on the athletic field, in the classroom, socially, and, when nosotros became adults, in terms of earning power. He didn't love me for who I was; he only cared most reflected glory. I pledged never to do that to my own children whom I love for who they are."

In the world of self-help, these parents frequently earn the label of narcissists. But no matter how you label information technology, the emotional wounds they inflict on their children are many.

six. To keep your union together (or to become someone to marry you lot in the first place).

Despite all the articles in the pop press, all the studies, and all the cautionary tales presented in novels and movies, people still appear to believe that a baby can heal a relationship already nether stress. Of course, naught could be farther from the truth. And while disagreements over kid-rearing aren't among the top three reasons people divorce—those remain adultery, drug or alcohol abuse, and money—they are extremely common. Hither's the affair: Just equally lovers wrongly believe they'll simply smoothen over disagreements most money, couples tend not to discuss their views virtually raising children alee of fourth dimension. Equally i human being told me: "I wouldn't say that our fights nearly our son were the main reason for our divorce but I would say that they were the proverbial straw-that-broke-the-camel's dorsum. My ex-wife consistently refused to discipline him in childhood and and then adolescence and when, in early on machismo, he was unable to have responsibility for his deportment, she simply turned a blind eye. I simply couldn't accept that."

A young woman in her early forties, now the divorced mother of an eight-year-sometime, reflected: "The tensions in our marriage were already evident only, looking back, I don't retrieve either of the states was really ready to get honest about what was going on. We'd been married 7 years and were living more and more parallel lives. Nosotros weren't fighting but nosotros weren't connecting either and I don't think we understood it. When our son was born, my focus shifted even more, away from the marriage. It only took a few years for it all to unravel, unfortunately."

And then, of course, there's the child for whom the parents "have to" marry. Ane adult daughter shared the post-obit story:

"Fifty-fifty though my parents stayed married and went on to have three other children, their attitude toward me was always different. I was the one who'd 'robbed' my mother of her youth and her higher education when she got pregnant junior yr. I was the one who put so much pressure on my father when he wasn't ready to take it on. I am at present in my tardily forties and they still oasis't really 'forgiven' me for something I had nothing to do with. Unless, of grade, you can be blamed for being born."

The good news, of course, is that your original motivation for having a child need not dictate how you parent if y'all are willing to be honest with yourself and work hard at seeing how your unconscious, unarticulated, and unacknowledged needs—not your child'southward—are influencing your behavior. Every bit Daniel Siegel and Mary Hartzell, authors of Parenting from the Inside Out (which I think is the all-time volume on this tender subject) write:

"When nosotros are fully nowadays equally parents, when we are mindful, it enables our children to fully experience themselves in the moment. Children learn about themselves past the mode we communicate with them. When we are preoccupied with the by or worried near the time to come, we are physically present with our children but are mentally absent-minded. Children don't need u.s.a. to be fully available all the fourth dimension, only they do demand our presence during connecting interactions. Existence mindful every bit a parent means having intention in your actions."

Permitting why yous decided to have a kid—particularly if it was all nigh you, every bit these six motives are—to boss your behavior is to cull to exist absent. No matter why you decided to become a mother or father, working to be as present every bit you can be in your interactions with the person yous put on the planet is an of import lesson to take to heart and continue in the forefront of your mind.

Read Mean Mothers: Overcoming the Legacy of Hurt.

Copyright Peg Streep 2015

huiepropis.blogspot.com

Source: https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/tech-support/201512/6-terrible-reasons-anyone-have-child

Share this post